2016年12月11日 星期日

Japan’s humble school lunch: social leveler and sacred cow





http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2016/12/10/business/japans-humble-school-lunch-social-leveler-sacred-cow

Japan’s humble school lunch: social leveler and sacred cow

BY  AND 
SPECIAL TO THE JAPAN TIMES
On Oct. 25, the education department of Suzuka, Mie Prefecture, sent notices to the city’s 30 elementary schools and 13 junior high schools saying that school lunches would not be served on Dec. 20 and Jan. 12. The reason, it said, was a sharp increase in the price of vegetables owing to bad weather this past summer. The budget was overburdened, and the department felt that the two days selected would have the least negative impact on students because Dec. 20 was the last school day of the year and Jan. 12 was the first school day of 2017, so schedules would be irregular anyway.
This very local news received a fair amount of coverage in the national press, and some media called the city for further clarification. As it turns out, the hot lunch program for Suzuka’s schools was running a net deficit. The monthly lunch fee for elementary school students had been increased in 2014 from ¥4,000 to ¥4,100. Junior high schools, on the other hand, had only started serving school lunches in May, and they charged ¥4,700 a month. A bureaucrat told the Mainichi Shimbun that the city “couldn’t help but cut lunches for those two days,” because, in accordance with rules set by the education ministry, it had to “meet certain nutritional standards,” and in order to do that it would have to purchase certain ingredients that have become more expensive in recent months.
“We can’t increase the lunch fee suddenly in the middle of the year,” the representative told the Mainichi, “so we hope parents understand this is a better solution.” Two weeks later, after media reports engendered a backlash, the city rescinded the cancelation.
But Suzuka wasn’t the only local government wrestling with this problem. Nagoya is looking for “cheaper ingredients” by soliciting different vendors and changing some items on its menus. The nearby city of Gifu has not changed its lunch menu or the volume of portions, but it is eliminating dessert, which isn’t served every day, as well as the amount of beef in its curry rice. It is also thinking of replacing pricier spinach with cheaper bean sprouts or Chinese cabbage. As of this fall, parents of elementary school students were paying ¥250 per meal, each of which cost the city ¥262; for junior high school students the price is ¥299 and the city pays ¥303. The difference is only a few yen, but multiplied by thousands of students a day, every day, it adds up.
The reason school lunches receive so much attention is that in Japan they are considered part of the public school curriculum, an aspect of growing up that means more than just stable nutrition. Japan is famous around the world for the high quality of its school lunches. Beyond the inculcation of good eating habits and an appreciation of wholesome food, Japan’s school lunch program stresses the importance of community by having students pitch in with serving and cleaning, and, more to the point, it makes children understand their responsibilities within the group, which is why so many schools mandate that all their students buy lunch.
Almost all public elementary schools in Japan have mandatory school lunch programs. For junior high schools it hasn’t always been an obligation, but in recent years more have made it so — about 80 percent of them at last count. Long before World War II, when lunch wasn’t mandatory, it wasn’t unusual for many children to skip lunch, a situation that made for a kind of class divide: well-to-do students brought packed lunches from home while children from poorer families just did without. As Japan modernized, building strong young bodies for the sake of the country became government policy, and the only way to guarantee that everyone ate lunch was to make school lunches mandatory and unify menus.
After the war, school lunch programs became even more systematized and were exploited by the American Occupation, which addressed the country’s acute food shortage by giving schools lots of free wheat and powdered milk to develop young Japanese people’s tastes for bread and dairy products, thus creating future consumers of American exports. Because of demographic differences, big cities were slower to get with the program. Yokohama, for instance, has never had a mandatory school lunch system for its junior high schools.
Students whose families receive public assistance can have their school lunches subsidized by the government, and even those who do not receive welfare but whose families may not be able to afford school lunches can get some kind of reimbursement. These policies are more social than economic in purpose, since the real meaning of mandatory school lunches is psychological: No child should feel inferior or superior to classmates because everyone eats the same thing for lunch.
In that regard, more attention is being paid to school lunch scofflaws — parents who have been delinquent in paying for their children’s lunches. The city of Osaka reported that the amount of nonpayment has reached ¥100 million, and last month it engaged a group of lawyers to hound such parents. The lawyers essentially act like a collection agency.
The education ministry says that nationwide, the school lunch nonpayment bill has reached ¥2 billion a year. According to its own survey, only 30 percent of parents don’t pay because of financial limitations. Sixty percent are simply “irresponsible.”
Educator Sakiko Gan, who has written two books about Japan’s school lunch program, says that for many low-income students, lunch is the main meal of the day. It’s part of the social safety net, so it is incumbent on schools to be consistent in their lunch policy. Generally speaking, the price that parents pay goes only to materials. Everything else — personnel, delivery costs, overheads — is covered by taxes.
Gan thinks the media has overstated the nonpayment problem. Two billion yen sounds like a lot, but it only represents 0.9 percent of the combined school lunch budgets for the whole country. On the other hand, school lunches comprise a major portion of parents’ education outlay, which also includes uniforms, excursions and extracurricular activities. In some areas, school lunches make up as much as 90 percent of this outlay. Each public elementary school student needs, altogether, about ¥100,000 a year, whereas a junior high school student costs ¥170,000, and that doesn’t include the cost of cram schools.
Gan says the education ministry survey is not rigorous. The government surveys schools, not parents themselves, and she believes school officials are quick to stereotype people.
“They see parents with nice clothes who aren’t paying their school lunch fees and they think they’re cheating,” she said recently on a discussion on TBS Radio. But school officials don’t actually know those parents’ financial situations.
Underscoring the importance of school lunches in household finances, the city of Aioi in Hyogo Prefecture has seen success in recent years with a program to attract young families by making all school lunches free. Before the policy was enacted, the city was losing 200 households a year. Since it was enacted they’ve reversed that trend and gained 100 households a year. Families, it seems, will go where they know they can save money.

王盈勛:台灣教育史上最貴的千億騙局;嚴長壽批評教育:孩子自律能力?讓爛博士去開計程車"台灣博士教育泡沫何時破滅"?2012/


台灣教育史上最貴的千億騙局是什麼?就是原本可以用常態性預算發給各大學,讓他們依自己的需求,發展自己特色的政府與大學間的關係,公部門偏要扣下其中的一大部分,橫生各種計畫要眾家大學來申請。
官方對這種做法的解釋是,競爭性計畫有助於大學力求進步。儘管這些計畫名目雖多,都無從擺脫兩條潛規則的牽制:一是依傳統學校排名分錢,二是最終通通有獎不得罪人。...http://bit.ly/2feYWEI
— — —
台灣高教到底出了哪些問題,為什麼 #教卓 與 #頂尖大學計劃 還是招致批評?
● 當官僚也搞起市場競爭──是誰讓大學忙著打假球?
http://bit.ly/2feRD01
● 荒謬的經費政策,讓大學逐漸失去自主與自由
http://bit.ly/2eWBGOH
已故的經濟思想家、諾貝爾獎得主寇斯(Ronald…
OPINION.CW.COM.TW|作者:獨立評論在天下



(中央社記者許秩維台北11日電)公益平台文化基金會董事長嚴長壽今天表示,未來孩子可能18歲就變公民,卻沒教他們思辨能力,孩子在網路時代享受自由,卻沒有自律能力。

2016學思達亞洲年會今天舉行第二天會議,邀請教育部次長陳良基、公益平台文化基金會董事長嚴長壽、誠致教育基金會董事長方新舟、BTS無界塾創辦人、台大電機系教授葉丙成等人進行教育願景座談。

現在網路教學在全世界鋪天蓋地,嚴長壽表示,最優秀的教學都在網路平台,線上學習能有助於打開更寬廣的領域,未來從線上學習,不單是要超越,還要有獨到的方法。

嚴長壽提到,現在台灣比任何一國更狹隘,過去每個部會都有國際組織,現在都刪除,公務人員沒有國際性,每個縣市長只要聽到風災,即使在國外也會趕回來,就因為台灣的民粹;未來孩子可能18歲就變公民,卻沒教他們思辨能力,孩子在網路時代享受自由,卻沒有自律能力。1051211


~~~~
這篇的議題不只是台灣的博士之品質/還包括校長遴選制等等問題 (讀者也應該知道亞都飯店如何訓練服務人員應對計程車司機.....)


嚴長壽:讓爛博士去開計程車
.作者: 劉東皋 | 臺灣時報 – 2012年11月11日 上午1:01.. .

 〔記者劉燊台中報導〕近年來積極關心教育的嚴長壽,昨日在豐原一場演講中,直批台灣的大學教育失敗與失策。

一家建設公司數年來與市議員陳清龍服務處合作,每年購買大批書籍贈送給山城地區中小學,今年特別大量採購嚴長壽的著作「教育應該不一樣」做為贈書。嚴長壽昨天受邀到到豐原陽明大樓進行一場演講,吸引上千名學校教師與關心教育的家長、民眾前來,很多人席地而坐,更多的人站在樓上、樓下走道兩旁聽講。

嚴長壽極度憂心台灣僵化的教育,將使台灣失去競爭力。尤其針對台灣大學教育,有相當的批評。

嚴長壽對政府要以補助方式,協助博士畢業生就業的做法,頗不認同。他說,如果博士畢業生本身缺乏競爭力,「讓這些爛博士去開計程車好了」,而不是還要由政府給予補助就業。話才說完,引起現場近千名聽眾大力鼓掌。

另外,他表示,他原本受台灣大學之托,有意參與台大校長遴選之工作。他期望遴選委員會能到國際上邀請優秀的人才到台大擔任校長,即使三顧茅廬,也要把不願意前來的優秀人才極力邀來。但台大後來仍希望透過教授投票的方式產生校長。嚴長壽認為,這對一些有心帶領學校邁向國際及頂尖的人才,是一種障礙。

嚴長壽說,台灣近幾來很流行用一個字形容台灣。他自己認為最恰當的一個字是「寵」。台灣如今是大人寵小孩,政治人物寵選民,政府官員寵民意代表。如果校長必須透過教授投票產生,有時候為了討好「選民」,而不敢全力作為與治理,這對學校的發展,極為不利。

另外,經常受邀到各大學演講的嚴長壽說,他到一些大學演講時,常在教室外看到很多學生打瞌睡。他問校長為何有這麼多學生打瞌睡?校長說這些學生很辛苦,晚上還要打工。他反問校長,學生如果學習效果差,不是應該當掉?校長卻回說,不能當,因為當一個就少一個。

嚴長壽憂心說,學生打工賺錢付學費,學校怕當掉學生沒有收入,就這樣讓學生打工賺錢養學校,混了四年後再給學生一張沒有競爭力的文憑。這樣的大學及大學教育,在台灣還不知有多少。

他指出,如今一年出生人口僅剩十六萬六千人,但必須有三十多萬學生才能養活現在的大學家數。等於未來必須要一個學生讀兩個大學,否則有一半的學校要倒閉。台灣的大學過剩、早晚有學校要關門,但政府卻還沒有好好規劃、制訂大學退場機制。

他也憂心,台灣的博士有多少是在不夠嚴謹的教育下而產出的?這些缺乏競爭力的博士畢業生,政府還要編預算補助他們就業,卻不去探討、並改善基本原因,從根本解決問題。造成多少學生浪費生命在大學讀書,拿了大學或碩博士文憑,卻毫無競爭力,浪費了無數的生命和社會資源。

他無奈的表示,台灣的一些政府官員很像在上電視機智問答節目,每天上台,面對民意代表、媒體、上級的問話,天天在機智問答,而自己頭上掛著的一個大汽球則愈漲愈大。不少官員的心態,只是擔心自己頭上的汽球不要在他任內漲破就好,卻不去想辦法讓汽球消氣(解決問題)。

■ 新聞民調/2012十大新聞票選


2011.5.3 這篇"台灣博士教育泡沫何時破滅" 是否可以類推至"台灣的各極教育泡沫何時破滅"?
這是一麻煩的問題
讀者現在只能了解一些相對的數字和部分的"社會"/經濟效應而已.....


----

意見評論 05/01/2011
由美國運通小弟出身,亞都麗緻集團董事長嚴長壽先生日前在他新書發表會上,對台灣高等教育當前的發展有非常深刻而嚴峻的 批判。嚴先生的一些觀點是「找大師到學校做短期的講座教授是作秀」、「爭取世界排名是沒有必要的虛榮」等等,過去在學界中也偶而會聽到類似的討論,但多半 屬於在地下流傳的「耳語」。學界領袖的媚俗與對權勢的曲阿附勢早就形成了一個「共錯結構」,難以有所期待。因此,能否正面回應嚴先生對高等教育的批判,是 對臺灣學界靈魂的一次考驗。

嚴先生的批判不僅每一項都點到了臺灣台灣高等教育的痛處,其中「台灣中間空掉了,沒有腳踏實地的基礎人力,許多碩博士卻變成駐家的宅男宅女,找不 到未來。」更觸及到一個過去很少人討論,但對高等教育潛在的傷害至為深遠的課題:「博士培養人數過剩與就業市場的前景泡沬化」!其實這個問題不只發生在台 灣,它同時也早己經在歐美學界中持續醱酵,例如去年年底,英國「經濟學人」就發表了一篇討論歐美學界博士製造過剩、供需失衡的文章。標題是 「免洗學術:為何念博士往往是浪費時間 」(The disposable academic: Why doing a PhD is often a waste of time)。這篇文章的中文版在臺大科學教育發展中心的部落格中揭露後,曾在研究生中引起廣泛的討論。
過去十年中,台灣大學生人數從六十八萬增加到一百零二萬,成長百分之五十。但同一時期,碩士班人數從八萬七干人增加到十八萬五干人,成長百分之一 百二十六;而博士班人數從一萬六干人增加到三萬四干人,成長百分之一百一十三。在博士班中,科技類佔的比率從九十學年的百分之七十一降低到九十九學年的百 分之六十八。顯示這段期間人文社會博士班學生人數的成長甚至高於科技類。
人文社會學科博士班學生的教職出路,早已從科技大學下修到高中。隨著少子化帶來科技大學的萎縮,整個系所的整併與裁撤更是時有所聞。學生踏入這個 領域之前有沒有充份瞭解未來職場的前景?博士班除了專業之外,對修業年限、論文的要求、多元能力的訓練等等,有沒有考慮現實環境的限制與學生未來的需求而 作適度的調整?對研究生教育的整体規劃與對博士班學生生涯發展的輔導,幾乎所有的大學都交了白卷!
另一個弔詭的現象是生物醫學領域博士班學生人數不成比例地增加。九十學年到九十九學年,科技類博士班人數從一萬一千人增加到兩萬三千人,成長百分 之一百零三。但生物醫學領域的人數則從一千兩百人增加到三千八百人(包括中研院的四百人) ,成長幅度高達百分之兩百一十六。生醫領域博士生的成長是科技類的兩倍,是毫無道理甚或是近乎荒唐的事。生技產業過去十年其實仍然停留在夢幻般的空中樓台 上,而未來的前景完全看不出有任何樂觀的預期。在這樣的客觀環境下,博士生的大幅增加完全是學界、政府與社會彼此吹噓哄騙的結果。
學界務虛不實的承諾(世界排名與生技產業) ,讓無能的政府與無知的社會信以為真,漫無章法地撤錢與擴充研究機構的軟硬体。接下來當然就是讓一群群「天真浪漫」的年青學子,步入這個貌似夢幻,而其實 沒有太多內涵的博士訓練。老師心中掛念的只有實驗、論文與sci的點數。在很多老師眼裡,學生只是另一雙聽話的手而已。怎麼培養學術品味、知性與能力的提 昇永遠無法成為博士教育的核心價值。
台灣博士教育的泡沫化代表的是一整個世代人才的荒廢,我們還容忍讓多少個世代的年青人繼續在這個泡沬中幻滅?
【知識通訊評論月刊一○三期】2011.05.01