Some of the News Fit to Print
Some of the News Fit to Print
ABOUT HIGHER ED
CONNECT THE DOTSNancy L. Zimpher, chancellor of the State University of New York, writes in
Inside Higher Ed: A plan in Connecticut to legislate the end of most remedial education courses in public higher education has once again raised questions about why so many incoming students are not prepared for college-level work and what can be done about it. To fully comprehend and effectively address the nation’s reliance on remediation, it is important to look at some basic facts surrounding the issue. We do not have a system of public education in this country. As a nation, we have yet to connect the dots between early childhood programming, kindergarten learning, elementary and secondary education coursework, and college curriculums. Until we do, the issue of remediation – and the excessive costs associated with it in every state – will carry on.
FOR-PROFIT ISN'T A MODEL FOR COMMUNITY COLLEGESDaniel LaVista provides this commentary in the
Los Angeles Times: Mark Schneider and Lu Michelle Yin, proponents of for-profit higher education, go on the offensive in their
April 11 Times Op-Ed article and criticize public community colleges for our graduation rates, which do need to improve. I have no quarrel with that fundamental truth. However, I do take issue with those who advocate for for-profit colleges, which have been publicly exposed for their own inadequate graduation rates. I hate to use the old cliche about glass houses, but Schneider and Yin are clearly throwing stones, particularly at those of us in the California community college system. As Schneider and Yin point out, for-profit colleges have come under much negative scrutiny in the last few years. But the authors' attempt to redirect it is not persuasive. Quite simply, it's important to consider the facts.
ABOUT K-12
SCHOOL TURNAROUND PUSH STILL A WORK IN PROGRESSThe federal program providing billions of dollars to help states and districts close or remake some of their worst-performing schools remains a work in progress after two years, with more than 1,200 turnaround efforts under way but still no definitive verdict on its effectiveness. The School Improvement Grant program, supercharged by a windfall of $3 billion under the federal economic-stimulus package in 2009, has jump-started aggressive moves by states and districts. To get their share of the SIG money, they had to quickly identify some of their most academically troubled schools, craft new teacher-evaluation systems, and carve out more time for instruction, among other steps. The article is in
Education Week.
REFOCUS ON CLASSROOM INSTRUCTION, BROOKINGS URGESJohn Thompson blogs in
This Week in Education: The contemporary data-driven "reform" movement, fundamentally, is a theoretical bank shot, where in the name of "output-based" accountability non-educators' change the subject away from teaching and learning in order to somehow improve teaching and learning. "
Choosing Blindly," by the Brookings Foundation's Grover Whitehurst and Matthew Chingos, is a reminder that the best way to improve classroom outcomes is to concentrate on the real interactions in the classroom and not some statistical models. The better approach, all along, would have been to target the interactions between flesh and blood students, teachers, and the learning materials that they actually use.
ABOUT K-12
WE DON'T JUDGE TEACHERS BY NUMBERS ALONE; THE SAME SHOULD GO FOR SCHOOLS
Michael J. Petrilli writes in the the Fordham Institute’s
Flypaper
blog: When it comes to evaluating teachers, there’s wide agreement that
we need to look at student achievement results—but not exclusively.
Teaching is a very human act; evaluating good teaching takes human
judgment—and the teacher’s role in the school’s life, and her students’
lives, goes beyond measurable academic gains. Thus the interest in
regular observations by principals and/or master teachers. So why do we
assume, when it comes to evaluating schools, that we must look at
numbers alone?
THE CRISIS IN AMERICAN EDUCATION IS A MYTH
Joplin, Missouri English teacher Randy Turner writes in the
Huffington Post:
One of the most frustrating things teachers have to deal with every day
is this myth that our profession is filled with lazy, undermotivated
educators who arrive just in time for the first bell and leave
immediately at the end of the school day. We watch as, year after year,
politicians devise radical plans that totally revamp our "failed"
system. Many times these plans involve taking public money and putting
it into private schools, relying more and more on standardized tests,
and tearing down the teachers who are the key to the success that public
education has always been and hopefully, after the fallout of this
well-organized attack, will continue to be.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
A MARKET FOR SUCCESS: HOW A ROBUST SERVICE PROVIDER MARKET CAN HELP COMMUNITY COLLEGES IMPROVE STUDENT COMPLETION
A new
report
by the nonprofit consulting firm FSG draws on the perspectives of
hundreds of community college leaders and field experts to explore how
external service providers can best help colleges improve student
completion. The research highlights what community colleges most need to
improve student success rates, explores the landscape of service
providers who can meet those needs, and offers recommendations on how to
build a robust market for external services that helps colleges deliver
stronger results.
FOR STUDENT SUCCESS, STOP DEBATING AND START IMPROVING
Hilary Pennington, director of education, postsecondary success, and
special initiatives at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation writes in
The Chronicle of Higher Education: Historically, higher
education has fueled social and economic mobility in America. But today
that contribution is at risk. Attainment gaps between high- and
low-income students have doubled over the past 10 years. Only 9 percent
of students from low-income households have earned any postsecondary
credentials by the time they are 26, compared with more than 50 percent
of students from higher-income households. We must do far more, and with
far more speed, than we are doing now to close this gap. If we can
ensure that the majority of today's low-income young adults earn
credentials beyond high school, they will qualify for family-supporting
jobs and set their children on a path of upward mobility—a powerful way
to break the intergenerational cycle of poverty.
posted Apr 10, 2012 11:43 am
Good teachers are crucial to student learning, but just how do you
measure a teacher’s effectiveness? That’s something many districts in
Illinois and around the country are grappling with as new laws prompted
by Race to the Top go into effect. Last week, Chicago Public Schools
released its new plan for evaluating teachers after months of
unsuccessful negotiations between the district and the Chicago Teachers
Union. The new system will factor in improvements in student test scores
to rate teachers, a move that doesn't sit well with the Chicago
Teachers Union. So what do we know about what makes a good teacher, and
what’s the best way to gauge a teacher’s skills? Carnegie Foundation
Senior Fellow
Thomas Toch and
Sara Ray Stoelinga from the University of Chicago’s Urban Education Institute discuss these questions and more on Chicago Public Media’s
Afternoon Shift.
Listen to the show »
ABOUT K-12
LA. SCHOOL CHOICE OPTIONS EXPAND AFTER SWEEPING EDUCATION OVERHAUL
Over the objections of teachers’ unions and many Democrats, Louisiana’s
Republican governor and GOP-controlled legislature have crafted one of
the most exhaustive education overhauls of any state in the country,
through measures that will dramatically expand families’ access to
public money to cover the costs of both private school tuition and
individual courses offered by a menu of providers. A pair of bills
championed by Gov. Bobby Jindal, which he is expected to sign into law,
will expand a state-run private-school-voucher program beyond New
Orleans to other academically struggling schools around the state, give
superintendents and principals direct control over personnel decisions,
and set much higher standards for awarding teachers tenure. The article
is in
Education Week.
IMPROVE STUDENT TEST SCORES, AND TEACHERS MIGHT GET A $1,600 BONUS
By the end of this school year, teachers at Romulus Middle School could
see a big payoff for their work in the last two years: bonuses of up to
$1,600 each for raising student test scores, volunteering to tutor kids
or developing training sessions for staff. The incentives are part of a
broad approach to improve teaching -- a key focus of the federal School
Improvement Grant (SIG) program that has invested more than $4.6 billion
into the nation's lowest-performing schools since 2009, including $83
million for 28 Michigan schools in 2010. The article is in the
Detroit Free Press.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COUNTING ALL STUDENTS
Rachel Fishman writes in Education Sector’s
The Quick and the Ed blog: On Wednesday, the
Department of Education released an action plan
to enhance postsecondary graduation rate data. If you’re not excited
about this, you should be. For years, we’ve been using
incomplete—woefully incomplete—completion data. And yet policymakers and
researchers have had no choice but to use this untrustworthy data. But
now that’s about to change. Given the inadequate picture we have about
postsecondary attainment, the Department of Education’s announcement to
improve graduation data is momentous. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan
said, “Better data across institutions is the basis for finding sound
solutions to help students stay in school and complete their
postsecondary studies. It is critical to their success and our nation’s
economic prosperity.”
THE GOVERNMENT'S NEW WAY OF MEASURING STUDENT SUCCESS: IMPLICATIONS FOR BLACK COLLEGES
The federal government recently announced that it plans to change the
way it measures student success. Instead of measuring graduation rates
using first-time, full-time students, the new measurements will take
into account part-time and transfer students. The Integrated
Postsecondary Educational Data System (IPEDS) has been outdated for
several decades now and fails to take into account the changing
landscape of students in the United States. This new change is good news
for many of the nation's colleges and universities. Although community
college leaders are the main force behind this change in measurement,
the new strategy will also have a significant impact on the measuring of
student success at Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs)
as well. The article is in
The Huffington Post.
ABOUT K-12
LA. SCHOOL CHOICE OPTIONS EXPAND AFTER SWEEPING EDUCATION OVERHAUL
Over the objections of teachers’ unions and many Democrats, Louisiana’s
Republican governor and GOP-controlled legislature have crafted one of
the most exhaustive education overhauls of any state in the country,
through measures that will dramatically expand families’ access to
public money to cover the costs of both private school tuition and
individual courses offered by a menu of providers. A pair of bills
championed by Gov. Bobby Jindal, which he is expected to sign into law,
will expand a state-run private-school-voucher program beyond New
Orleans to other academically struggling schools around the state, give
superintendents and principals direct control over personnel decisions,
and set much higher standards for awarding teachers tenure. The article
is in
Education Week.
IMPROVE STUDENT TEST SCORES, AND TEACHERS MIGHT GET A $1,600 BONUS
By the end of this school year, teachers at Romulus Middle School could
see a big payoff for their work in the last two years: bonuses of up to
$1,600 each for raising student test scores, volunteering to tutor kids
or developing training sessions for staff. The incentives are part of a
broad approach to improve teaching -- a key focus of the federal School
Improvement Grant (SIG) program that has invested more than $4.6 billion
into the nation's lowest-performing schools since 2009, including $83
million for 28 Michigan schools in 2010. The article is in the
Detroit Free Press.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COUNTING ALL STUDENTS
Rachel Fishman writes in Education Sector’s
The Quick and the Ed blog: On Wednesday, the
Department of Education released an action plan
to enhance postsecondary graduation rate data. If you’re not excited
about this, you should be. For years, we’ve been using
incomplete—woefully incomplete—completion data. And yet policymakers and
researchers have had no choice but to use this untrustworthy data. But
now that’s about to change. Given the inadequate picture we have about
postsecondary attainment, the Department of Education’s announcement to
improve graduation data is momentous. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan
said, “Better data across institutions is the basis for finding sound
solutions to help students stay in school and complete their
postsecondary studies. It is critical to their success and our nation’s
economic prosperity.”
THE GOVERNMENT'S NEW WAY OF MEASURING STUDENT SUCCESS: IMPLICATIONS FOR BLACK COLLEGES
The federal government recently announced that it plans to change the
way it measures student success. Instead of measuring graduation rates
using first-time, full-time students, the new measurements will take
into account part-time and transfer students. The Integrated
Postsecondary Educational Data System (IPEDS) has been outdated for
several decades now and fails to take into account the changing
landscape of students in the United States. This new change is good news
for many of the nation's colleges and universities. Although community
college leaders are the main force behind this change in measurement,
the new strategy will also have a significant impact on the measuring of
student success at Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs)
as well. The article is in
The Huffington Post.
ABOUT K-12
BILL GATES: MAKING TEACHER EVALUATIONS PUBLIC 'NOT CONDUCIVE TO OPENNESS'
Through his foundation, The Bill And Melinda Gates Foundation, Bill
Gates is known for pouring millions into education reform. So when he
came out in February against making Teacher Data Reports — or
evaluations — public in New York City, Gates made a splash. This is a
big deal, because his foundation has advocated for tougher
accountability standards for teachers, something teachers unions haven't
fully embraced. In an interview with
NPR’s Weekend Edition Saturday's host Scott Simon, Gates explained himself.
CALIFORNIA TEACHER RATINGS SHOULD BE RELEASED PUBLICLY, PARENTS SAY IN NEW SURVEY
While teachers and most education reformers remain highly uncomfortable
with having test-based teacher evaluations aired in public, one survey
suggests parents take a different view. In a new SurveyUSA news poll
that asked 500 California adults about "releasing performance ratings of
California public school teachers," 65 percent responded that they
supported the idea. Sixty-six percent indicated they believed releasing
teacher data would improve their performance, while 32 percent said they
thought it would discourage teachers from working in California. The
article is in
The Huffington Post.
QUESTIONS ABOUND AS DISTRICTS SHIFT TO MERIT PAY FOR TEACHERS
Education reforms now going into effect in Indiana, and similar ones
sweeping the nation, are targeting something many Americans consider to
be strictly off-limits: their paychecks. The laws passed in 2011 and
being implemented over the next two or three years were partly based on
the principle of merit pay. Under Indiana’s new law, the state will ask
that test performance of students be factored into pay raises for the
first time. That is a major shift away from the rigid pay tables in most
school districts that awarded raises primarily based on a teacher’s
years of experience and the academic degrees they earned. The article is
in
The Hechinger Report.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
CONNECTICUT MAY LET COLLEGE STUDENTS SKIP REMEDIAL CLASSES
Remedial classes could be slashed in Connecticut—but not because
students are prepared to do college-level work. Under a bill approved by
the state's Senate higher education committee, all community college
and state university students could take college-level, credit-bearing
courses with "embedded" remedial help for those who need it. That could
mean an additional skills class, a lab, or tutoring. The article is in
U.S. News & World Report.
TRYING TO FIND A MEASURE FOR HOW WELL COLLEGES DO
How well does a college teach, and what do its students learn? Rankings
based on the credentials of entering freshmen are not hard to find, but
how can students, parents and policy makers assess how well a college
builds on that foundation? What information exists has often been hidden
from public view. But that may be changing. In the wake of the No Child
Left Behind federal education law, students in elementary, middle and
high schools take standardized tests whose results are made public,
inviting anyone to assess, however imperfectly, a school’s performance.
There is no comparable trove of public data for judging and comparing
colleges. Pieces of such a system may be taking shape, however, with
several kinds of national assessments — including, most controversially,
standardized tests — gaining traction in recent years. More than 1,000
colleges may be using at least one of them. The article is in
The New York Times.
ABOUT K-12
HOW TO REBUILD NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND
Congressman Rob Andrews writes in
The Atlantic: When President
Obama addressed the nation in his State of the Union speech last year,
he challenged Congress to put aside its political differences and work
together to strengthen our education system. Over a year later, Congress
has failed to rise to the president's challenge. As a result, our
nation's educational performance continues to linger around the middle
of the pack among industrialized countries. As American corporations
continue to send quality jobs overseas, a mediocre education system will
not solve our economic crisis. Fixing our schools must be a national
priority. But to get there, we must overcome the gridlock in Washington
and reauthorize No Child Left Behind (NCLB).
THE TROUBLE WITH PAY FOR PERFORMANCE
Gerald Tirozzi, Marian Hermie, and Wayne Schmidt provide this commentary in
Education Week:
Virtually everyone agrees that educators should be held accountable for
student achievement, and pay for performance is often suggested as a
method for rewarding those teachers whose students demonstrate adequate
yearly progress, or AYP. The question is how to adequately and fairly
evaluate a teacher’s performance relative to how it affects student
achievement, and then to determine how to compensate those teachers
whose students demonstrate AYP or beyond. There is a dearth of research
that supports paying teachers beyond their base salaries to improve
student achievement, but there is a broad body of research that
indicates that pay for performance might actually do damage as teachers
feel a threat to their livelihoods because of this narrow method of
measuring their efficacy. Pay for performance has been documented as
compromising the good will and cooperation among teachers since it
creates competition for a small amount of money, which can result in an
“I’m out for myself only” attitude. Such a tone can hurt the necessary
collaboration and communication found to nurture student achievement and
success.
MATH EDUCATION IN AMERICA: EDUCATORS AND ENTREPRENEURS HAVE IDEAS TO MAKE IT FUN
In the American drive to boost science and math education, it's science
that has all the kid-friendly sizzle: Robots and roller coasters,
foaming chemical reactions, marshmallow air cannons. Math has... well,
numbers.
"America has a cultural problem with math. It's the subject, more than
any other, that we as a country love to hate," said Glen Whitney, a
passionate mathematician who worked for years developing algorithms for
hedge funds. "We don't see it as dynamic. It's rote and boring and done
by dead Greek guys a thousand years ago." A brave group of educators and
entrepreneurs think they can change that. With games and competitions,
museums and traveling road shows - and a strategic sprinkling of
celebrities - they aim to make math engaging, exciting and even fun. The
article is in
The Huffington Post.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
LAST RITES FOR GRADUATION RATE
A long-held wish of many community colleges is on the verge of becoming
reality: the Education Department has announced its plans to change how
student success is measured in higher education, taking into account
students who transfer, part-time students and students who are not
attending college for the first time. The department outlined its plans
Wednesday to carry out the recommendations of the Committee on Measures
of Student Success, a federal panel that called for changing how data on
completion rates and other measures at community colleges is reported
in the Integrated Postsecondary Educational Data System, or IPEDS. While
the recommendations are still several steps away from becoming reality
-- the department’s "action plan" talked about “taking steps” and
“examining the feasibility” of broadening the measures of success --
they are a victory for community colleges and their advocates, who have
complained for years that the federal data reporting system doesn’t
reflect the reality on their campuses. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
ABOUT K-12
BACK TO THE BASICS, INDEED: A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF EDUCATION RESEARCH
Elaine Weiss writes in
The Huffington Post: At a recent event
in New York City, Pedro Noguera, a sociologist at New York University,
bemoaned the political maneuvering and bickering over details that has
come to dominate education policy discussions. In all the arguing over
whether to open more charter schools or publicize teacher test scores,
he correctly noted that we often seem to ignore what is best for
students. What would clearly serve the country's children better is
putting our limited education dollars into what the evidence says works.
There is more than enough heated rhetoric about "evidence-based"
initiatives. Turn down the burners, however, and the research appears
quite a bit clearer.
WE DON’T JUDGE TEACHERS BY NUMBERS ALONE – THE SAME SHOULD GO FOR (SOME?) SCHOOLS
Anne Hyslop responds to yesterday’s
post
by Mike Petrilli on school accountability: I completely agree that
numbers – specifically test scores alone – cannot paint a complete
picture of school quality. There are numerous other pieces of
information – whether they are quantitative measures like AP success,
postsecondary enrollment, and college remediation rates, or qualitative
observations made by professional inspectors – that could inform our
perceptions of school performance. Given these practical concerns, I
think it makes sense to focus on where school inspections can add the
most value. And to me, that means focusing less on their use in
accountability and more on how they can inform school improvement. The
article is in the
Quick and the
Ed.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COMMUNITY COLLEGES' LEARNING DISABILITY
Mark Schneider and Lu Michelle Yin provide this commentary in the
Los Angeles Times:
Community colleges are central to the nation's higher education
system, enrolling almost 30% of all postsecondary students. But their
record of success is spotty. Nationally, only about a quarter of
full-time community college students complete their studies within three
years (the official measure of a school's graduation rate). This
happens year after year after year, and it's not only the dropouts who
are harmed. When students fail to complete their degrees, taxpayers also
lose. The question is: What can be done to make this happen?
2-YEAR COLLEGE RETIREMENT WAVE?
California's community colleges may be just a few years away from "a
retirement wave" for faculty members, a transition that could create
much better jobs for the part timers on whom campuses depend, according
to a survey being presented at the American Educational Research
Association's annual meeting, which starts this week. The study, based
on a survey of full-time and part-time faculty members throughout
California's mammoth community college system (the largest in the United
States), also points to the potential for campuses to more actively
engage prospective faculty members in their careers. While the survey
found great pride from many faculty members in their work and in the
community college mission, it found that many developed those ideas
"after the fact," with many instructors taking their first jobs without
any intention of making a career of it, or fully understanding the
nature of community college teaching. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
VOTERS VALUE EDUCATION
Calling education a “top-tier issue” in this year’s election, a new
College Board report
shows that swing state voters emphasize education as much as health
care despite a comparative lack of attention from candidates. In a
representative sample of about 200 registered voters surveyed in each of
nine swing states, 67 percent of respondents called education an
extremely important issue for this year’s election. Only jobs and the
economy (82 percent) and government spending (69 percent) scored higher.
The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
ABOUT K-12
BRAIN-IMAGING PERSPECTIVE ON TEACHER EVALUATION
Findings from a recent social neuroscience study reveal the profound
role status cues play in shaping our cognitive performance and suggest
that the sharp distinction between the social and cognitive brain is
artificial. These findings have implications for how and why rankings
matter in all human social endeavors and provide a new empirical
perspective to inform the current debate about whether and how to rank
teachers. The commentary is in
Education Week.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
TEACHER PREP ACCOUNTABILITY IS COMING
Sara Mead writes in
Education Week’s Policy Notebook blog:
Even as states and school districts at the K-12 level are moving to
adopt evaluations that hold teachers accountable for their impacts on
student learning, these efforts have largely ignored the need to improve
teacher preparation programs so that their graduates are actually
prepared to improve student learning. And the poor quality of most
existing teacher evaluation programs is one the few things that folks on
both sides of the increasingly polarized ed reform debates can agree
upon. If we want to move the teacher effectiveness debate beyond
deselection, we've got to get serious about how to make teacher prep way
more effective.
HIGHER EDUCATION VANISHING BEFORE OUR EYES
Even with top grades and extracurricular activities, students may find
it difficult to gain acceptance to or graduate from a four-year
university after recent cuts to higher education budgets. The month of
March has been particularly bad for colleges and universities
nationwide, as budget negotiations have left many institutions of higher
education in the red. The article is in
USA Today.
ABOUT K-12
ACCESS TO TEACHER EVALUATIONS DIVIDES ADVOCATES
As the movement to overhaul teacher evaluation marches onward, an
emerging question is splitting the swath of advocates who support the
new tools used to gauge teacher performance: Who should get access to
the resulting information? As evidenced in recently published opinion
pieces, the contours of the debate are rapidly being drawn. Some
proponents of using student-achievement data as a component of teacher
evaluations, including the philanthropist Bill Gates and Teach For
America founder Wendy Kopp, nevertheless believe that such information
should not be made widely public. Other figures, like New York City
Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, champion the broad dissemination of such
data. The article is in
Education Week.
CUOMO BACKS RELEASE OF TEACHER EVALUATIONS
ALBANY — Weighing in on the fight over releasing teachers’ evaluations
to the public, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo said Tuesday he’s inclined to
preserve open access for parents but willing to explore of shielding
the records in some way. “I believe in the case of teachers, the
parents’ right to know outweighs the teachers’ right to privacy,” the
governor said. “After that, it’s less clear to me. And that’s why I
think it warrants conversation.” The article is in the
Wall Street Journal.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
WHAT’S MORE EXPENSIVE THAN GOING TO COLLEGE? NOT GOING TO COLLEGE
There are 1.2 billion people between 15 and 24 in the world, according
to the International Youth Foundation’s new Opportunity for Action
paper. Although many of their prospects are rising, they are emerging
from conditions of widespread poverty and lack of access to the most
important means of economic mobility: education. In the Middle East and
North Africa, youth unemployment has been stuck above 20 percent for the
last two decades. And in the parts of the world where youth
unemployment has been low, such as south and east Asia, young people are
overwhelmingly employed in the agriculture sector, which leaves them
vulnerable to poverty. The article is in
The Atlantic.
ENROLLMENTS GROW, BUT MORE SLOWLY
As the recession took hold of the U.S. economy in late 2008, Americans
did what they often do in bad economic times: went back for more
schooling. That's why the last report from the federal government about
college and university enrollments showed a sharp increase (of 7.1
percent) in the number of students in postsecondary institutions in fall
2009. The upturn -- and the accompanying tuition dollars -- helped
soften the economic downturn's impact for many colleges. On Tuesday, the
Education Department's National Center for Education Statistics
reported
initial data on
the number of students who enrolled the following fall, in 2010. The
data show enrollments growing yet again, but at a somewhat slower pace,
with about 21.6 million students enrolled in fall 2010, up 2.8 percent
from a shade under 21 million in 2009. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
A SURGE IN LEARNING THE LANGUAGE OF THE INTERNET
Parlez-vous Python? What about Rails or JavaScript? Foreign languages
tend to wax and wane in popularity, but the language du jour is computer
code. The market for night classes and online instruction in
programming and Web construction, as well as for iPhone apps that teach,
is booming. Those jumping on board say they are preparing for a future
in which the Internet is the foundation for entertainment, education and
nearly everything else. Knowing how the digital pieces fit together,
they say, will be crucial to ensuring that they are not left in the dark
ages. The article is in
The New York Times.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COLLEGE COSTS ARE SOARING
Education is the great equalizer in this country. It is the
facilitator of the American Dream. People can grow up poor, in an urban
or rural setting, but can hope to pull themselves up out of poverty
with education. Unlike many other areas of the world, America mostly is
a meritocracy facilitated by education. As a society we have
recognized this and require elementary and high school education to be
provided “free” (paid by tax dollars) to all young people and most
states require attendance to age eighteen. Still, 15% of the U.S.
population does not have a high school diploma. College, on the other
hand, is voluntary and requires payment by the individual.
Unfortunately, only 17% of the U.S. population has earned an
undergraduate degree.. The article is in
Forbes magazine.
WATCHING THE IVORY TOWER TOPPLE
It is education's time to change. At the high-school level, interactive
study sites are increasingly ingenious: Look at Piazza, Blackboard and
Quizlet, founded by a 17-year-old. TED-Ed just launched a channel on You
Tube, with three- to 10-minute lessons for kids. YouTube's EDU Portal
has been viewed 22 billion times. Khan Academy, a favorite of Bill
Gates, has four million unique users a month and thousands of
educational videos, from "Napoleon's Peninsular Campaigns" to "Python
Lists." If you think that last one is about snakes, please download
Khan's new iPad app immediately. The next big thing, though, is
college-level MOOCs and MOOSes: Massive Open Online Courses and
Seminars. Harvard already showcases coursework like professor Michael
Sandel's "Justice" lectures online, gratis. Now Georgia Institute of
Technology, MIT, Stanford and others are offering advanced online
courses, some with accreditation. The article is in
The Wall Street Journal.
FOR-PROFIT EDUCATION SCAMS
Attorneys general from more than 20 states have joined forces to
investigate for-profit colleges that too often saddle students with
crippling debt while furnishing them valueless degrees. The
investigations have just begun. But it is already clear from testimony
before a Senate committee that Congress must do more to rein in the
schools and protect students. The commentary is in
The New York Times.
STRONG MAJORITY BACKS BROWN’S TAX HIKE
California voters strongly support Gov. Jerry Brown's new proposal to
increase the sales tax and raise levies on upper incomes to help raise
money for schools and balance the state's budget, according to a new USC
Dornsife/Los Angeles Times
poll. Sixty-four
percent of those surveyed said they supported the governor's measure,
which he hopes to place on the November ballot. It would hike the state
sales tax by a quarter-cent per dollar for the next four years and
create a graduated surcharge on incomes of more than $250,000 that would
last seven years. A third of respondents opposed the measure. The
article is in the
L.A. Times.
ABOUT K-12
MATH ANXIETY CHANGES BRAIN FUNCTION IN KIDS
Those of us who aren't that confident when it comes to math know well
that feeling of anxiety when faced with a problem requiring complex
calculations. That anxiety, it turns out, is more than just a case of
jitters. A
new study
by a team of scientists at Stanford University's School of Medicine
shows that the brain function of young elementary school kids who suffer
from math anxiety differs from those who don't, according to a report
on the university's website. The study led by Vinod Menon, a Stanford
professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences, was published online
this week in
Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. The article is in
Education Week.
CALIFORNIA URGED TO CONSIDER NON-SENIORITY BASED TEACHER LAYOFFS
California school districts issue more pink slips than necessary and
the state should consider alternatives to seniority-based layoffs,
according to a report from the state legislative analyst's office. In
the report, released last week, the nonpartisan analyst said that
because state and local budget information is available only after the
initial deadline for districts to send out layoff notices, more pink
slips are issued than may be needed. The article is in the
L.A. Times.
MISPLACED OPTIMISM AND WEIGHTED FUNDING
The Hoover Institute’s Eric Hanushek writes in
Education Week:
Liberals and conservatives alike have made "weighted student funding" a
core idea of their reform prescriptions. Both groups see such weighted
funding as providing more dollars to the specific schools they tend to
focus upon, and both see it as inspiring improved achievement through
newfound political pressures. Unfortunately, both groups are very likely
wrong.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
CAL STATE TRUSTEES HEAR GRIM FINANCIAL REPORT
The California State University Board of Trustees received a grim
report Tuesday on the consequences of more state funding cuts, including
slashing enrollment, losing thousands of faculty and staff positions,
and eliminating some academic and athletic programs. All of those are
possible if a tax measure on the November ballot fails and the system is
faced with a $200-million cut that would occur in the middle of the
2012-13 academic year, officials said. The article is in the
L.A. Times.
ABOUT K-12
TEACHER TURNOVER AFFECTS ALL STUDENTS’ ACHIEVEMENT, STUDY INDICATES
When teachers leave schools, overall morale appears to suffer enough
that student achievement declines—both for those taught by the departed
teachers and by students whose teachers stayed put, concludes
a study
recently presented at a conference held by the Center for Longitudinal
Data in Education Research. The impact of teacher turnover is one of the
teacher-quality topics that's been hard for researchers to get their
arms around. The phenomenon of high rates of teacher turnover has
certainly been proven to occur in high-poverty schools more than
low-poverty ones. The eminently logical assumption has been that such
turnover harms student achievement. The post is in
Education Week’s Teacher Beat blog.
VENTURE CAPITALISTS ON FUTURE OF TECH IN EDUCATION
A venture capitalist panel at SXSW interactive conference has discussed
the future of education technology. The panelists, Mitch Kapor, Phillip
Bronner and Rob Hutter claimed to have a broad vision of investing that
looked for technology to be more than just successful but that also
created social value. The article is from EdNews.org.
PANEL ENDORSES MAINE TEACHER EVALUATION BILL
AUGUSTA, Maine—A bill requiring rigorous performance evaluations for
Maine teachers and principals has been unanimously endorsed by a
legislative committee. The Education and Cultural Affairs Committee on
Wednesday voted 12-0 to send it to the full Legislature with an "ought
to pass" recommendation. The AP article is in the
Boston Globe.
MAYBE IT’S TIME TO ASK THE TEACHERS
Stanford professor Linda Darling-Hammond writes in the
Huffington Post:
American teachers deal with a lot: low pay, growing class sizes and
escalating teacher-bashing from politicians and pundits. Federal testing
and accountability mandates under No Child Left Behind and, more
recently, Race to the Top, have added layers of bureaucracy while
eliminating much of the creativity and authentic learning that makes
teaching enjoyable. Tack on the recession's massive teacher layoffs and
other school cuts, plus the challenges of trying to compensate for
increasing child poverty, homelessness, and food insecurity, and you get
a trifecta of disincentives to become, or remain, a teacher.
ABOUT K-12
ARNE DUNCAN: NEWSPAPERS SHOULDN’T PUBLISH TEACHER RATINGS
Publishing teachers' ratings in the newspaper in the way
The New York Times and
other outlets have done recently is not a good use of performance data,
U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan said in an interview
yesterday. "Do you need to publish every single teacher's rating in the
paper? I don't think you do," he said. "There's not much of an upside
there, and there's a tremendous downside for teachers. We're at a time
where morale is at a record low. ... We need to be sort of strengthening
teachers, and elevating and supporting them. The post is from
Education Week’s Teacher Beat blog.
CAREER MAPPING EYED TO PREPARE STUDENTS FOR COLLEGE
About half of all states mandate that schools help create individual or
student learning plans, and most others have optional programs.
Enabling students to make their own plans puts them in the driver’s seat
and encourages a long-term look at their course selection so their
choices match their career goals, experts say. Often, districts give
students online accounts with passwords to track classes; create an
electronic portfolio of grades, test scores, and work; research careers;
and organize their college search. The practice is picking up momentum
with the increased emphasis on college completion, which research shows
is more likely when students take rigorous courses and have a career
goal. The article is in
Education Week.
BAY AREA GETS POOR GRADES ON ABILITY TO EDUCATE MINORITIES, LOW-INCOME STUDENTS
Bay Area school districts barely get passing grades for how well they
teach minority and low-income students, according to a report released
by an education advocacy group Thursday. Of the 147 unified school
districts statewide that were ranked, Palo Alto Unified scored next to
last, earning a grade-point average of 1.0 -- a D. The report did not
award any A's. Palo Alto's low grade was one of many startling findings
in the 2011 California District Report Cards put out by the
Oakland-based Education Trust-West. The article is in the
San Jose Mercury News.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
THE PUZZLE OF STUDENT RESPONSIBILITY FOR LEARNING
Stanford professor Larry Cuban writes: In higher education, professors
give lectures and conduct seminars. While there is some talk of holding
professors accountable for what their students learn, that rhetoric has
yet to move beyond words. Undergraduate and graduate students are
expected to learn what professors teach. Yet in K-12 public schools, for
teachers, another helping profession, the reverse is true. For the past
quarter-century, responsibility for student learning for been put
completely on the shoulders of teachers (much less so in parochial and
independent private schools, however). And that is the puzzle. How come
K-12 public school teachers are expected to take full responsibility for
student learning and in the other helping professions that
responsibility is either shared with clients and patients or absent?
(Thanks to Alexander Russo’s
This Week in Education blog for pointing me to this post.) This post is from Cuban’s
School Reform blog.
HIGHER EDUCATION’S KODAK MOMENT
Lumina President Jamie Merisotis writes in
The Washington Times:
The recent bankruptcy declaration by Kodak, one of the nation’s most
trusted brands for consumers, which once held a market share in excess
of 90 percent, is stunning. Kodak mistook America’s century-long love
affair with its products as a sign of market permanency, missing the
fact that camera phones, flip cameras and online sharing would erode its
brand and render it irrelevant. American higher education should take
heed because it is facing a similar challenge, with implications far
more important than the loss of a major corporation.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COMMUNITY COLLEGE ASSOCIATION REBUKES REPORT THAT CRITICIZES THE SECTOR’S LOW GRADUATION RATES
The American Association of Community Colleges posted a blistering
statement on its Web site Wednesday in response to
a report released
by the American Enterprise Institute earlier this week that criticized
the low graduation rates of community-college students. The report went
on to say that those low rates affect the lifetime earnings of students
and the coffers of state governments. The association called the report a
piece of “shoddy work” and its analysis a “pseudo-academic attack on
community colleges.” In particular, it questioned the methodology used
to arrive at the report’s graduation rates. The association also said it
“begs to differ” with the report’s suggestion that community colleges
emulate for-profit colleges. This information is from
The Chronicle of Higher Education.
CHANCELLOR ASKS COMMUNITY COLLEGES TO HOLD OFF ON TWO-TIER TUITION PLAN
LOS ANGELES — The chancellor of the California community college system
has requested that Santa Monica College hold off on its plan to begin
offering popular courses for a higher price this summer, saying that
the legality of the program is still in question. The request, made on
Wednesday, came a day after a campus police officer sprayed more than
two dozen people with pepper spray as students tried to enter a trustees
meeting; several suffered minor injuries. Many students and advocates
have criticized the tuition plan, saying it violates the long tradition
of community colleges as havens for those who cannot afford four-year
colleges. The article is in
The New York Times.
NO AGREEMENT ON NEW RULES
WASHINGTON -- As a deadline approached for the federal panel charged
with recommending new rules for teacher education programs, negotiators
had a message for the Education Department: It’s not over 'til (we say)
it’s over. The panel is considering controversial proposals that could
change how teacher education programs are evaluated, including taking
graduates’ job placement rates and classroom performance into account
when deciding whether programs are eligible for students to receive
federal financial aid. But as discussions unfolded, the panel was far
from agreement on many key issues, despite a deadline of noon Thursday
-- and it eventually persuaded federal negotiators to agree to another
meeting next week. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
HAS HIGHER EDUCATION STIFFED ITS MOST IMPORTANT CLIENT?
The system's flaws are apparent from the first day a newly hired
professor walks into a classroom. After finishing their dissertations,
PhDs are hired by a college, based on publication records, the
reputations of their references, and the name of their graduate
programs. If they happen to have picked up a little classroom experience
through a temporary position, it is rarely considered by hiring
committees. Unlike other educators, college professors receive no formal
instruction on how to teach. Newly minted PhDs are expected to teach
Introduction to Political Science or Macroeconomics to 35-200 students
without training in classroom management, pedagogy, and assessment. They
have had no mentorships or student teacher training. Would you go to a
dentist who never learned how to drill teeth? In addition, their
graduate education forced them specialize to such an extent that many
find it difficult to convey the wide breadth of knowledge that is
required in lower level, undergraduate classes, the very meat of a
college education. The article is in
The Atlantic.
ABOUT K-12
A COLLECTION OF ESSAYS ON EDUCATION REFORM
To complement Education Sector’s “Getting to 2014” event, and more
specifically to generate thoughtful ideas for discussion, they asked
several experts to share their thoughts on the challenges of
implementing so many reforms, including new assessments, accountability
and data systems, teacher evaluations, and Common Core standards, all at
once.The contributors, including Michael Cohen, Robert Balfanz of Johns
Hopkins University, Public Impact’s Bryan and Emily Hassel, Allan
Odden, and Education Sector’s Bill Tucker, discuss five of these
dilemmas:
• How do we successfully implement new accountability systems and
interventions during the transition to new standards and assessments?
• How do we maintain the rigor of college- and career-ready standards without pushing more students out of the system?
• How do we adopt fair teacher evaluation systems based on student assessments when those assessments are set to change?
• How do we move toward more standardization while also promoting innovation?
• How can we execute multiple, complex reforms in a time of limited resources?
GETTING (STUDENT-) CENTERED
A
new report from
the Students at the Center project by Jobs for the Future examines what
districts will need to implement student-centered learning to improve
student achievement. To understand the current state of the work, the
authors reviewed research on high-performing districts and examined the
scope of commonly defined student-centered practices in districts and
charter schools. The authors observed that although districts are
essential actors in these reforms, they are not deeply involved in
implementing student-centered practices. Most examples of district
engagement are programmatic, tailored to serve particular student groups
rather than all of a system's students. Before implementing
student-centered approaches, districts will need to assess policy and
administrative requirements and state accountability measures that can
impede or support these approaches. A strong, district-wide
student-centered agenda would likely include implementing special
programs and/or schools, as well as working simultaneously to change
practice in all schools and for all students. Expanding student-centered
approaches will require district leadership, as it is not easy to
change teacher practice and classroom culture. Knowledge about how other
districts support reforms can inform implementation, and districts must
be strategic and deliberative in reform efforts, considering a full
range of student-centered options and evidence. This comes from the
PEN NewsBlast.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
EXPLOSION IN STUDENT DEBT REACHING CRISIS PROPORTIONS
Surging above $1 trillion, U.S. student loan debt has surpassed credit
card and auto-loan debt. This debt explosion jeopardizes the fragile
recovery, increases the burden on taxpayers and possibly sets the stage
for a new economic crisis. With a still-wobbly jobs market, these loans
are increasingly hard to pay off. Unable to find work, many students
have returned to school, further driving up their indebtedness. Average
student loan debt recently topped $25,000, up 25 percent in 10 years.
And the mushrooming debt has direct implications for taxpayers, since 8
in 10 of these loans are government-issued or guaranteed. The article,
which takes the opposite view of a
piece yesterday from CNN, is in
The Washington Post.
PRO-AFFIRMATIVE ACTION SUIT REJECTED
WASHINGTON -- A federal appeals court on Monday rejected a suit that
sought to lift California's ban on the consideration of race or
ethnicity in the admissions decisions of public colleges and
universities. Of late, supporters and critics of affirmative action have
been focused on a case before the U.S. Supreme Court dealing with the
consideration of race and ethnicity by the University of Texas at
Austin. The Texas case will decide whether a public university that has
achieved some level of diversity through race-neutral means can
consider race and ethnicity to achieve a greater level of diversity. The
article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
ABOUT K-12
STATES MOVE TO CLOSE OFF TEACHER EVALUATIONS
Tennessee is poised to pass a law exempting teachers’ evaluations from
broad disclosure under the state's open-records laws. And next up could
be the state of New York, where a similar proposal is under discussion,
according to the
Wall Street Journal. The post is from the
Politics K-12 blog in
Education Week.
UNFLATTENING THE TEACHING PROFESSION
One of the chief challenges to the teaching profession's status as a
profession is its flatness. A first-year teacher has the same duties and
working conditions as a 30-year veteran, and while the latter may be
higher on the pay scale, not much else changes as a teacher (or a
principal, for that matter) gains experience and expertise. The post is
from
Teacher Beat blog in
Education Week.
STATE SEEKS STILL MORE TESTS FOR STUDENTS
Like a luxury hotel or a swanky restaurant, your neighborhood school
could soon get an elite five-star rating. Then again, it could also get
four, three or two stars — or even hit bottom as a one-star school with
poor test scores and other big problems. Joining a wave of states
embarking on controversial reforms, Illinois is moving to overhaul how
students are tested and schools judged, with the proposed "star" rating
system just one element of a dramatic plan aimed at shaking up a decade
of status quo. The article is in the
Chicago Tribune.
STATES GIRD TO REPORT REVISED GRADUATION RATES
States are grappling with a federal requirement that is forcing them to
use a new, more uniform method of calculating high school graduation
rates—a method that, in some states, is yielding rates that are 20
percentage points lower than those states have reported in the past.
Under a 2008 update federal education rules, the states were required to
replace their patchwork of graduation-rate formulas with a four-year
"cohort" rate, beginning in the 2010-11 school year, and to use that
number this school year to determine whether schools are making adequate
progress under the No Child Left Behind Act. The article is in
Education Week.
ABOUT K-12
GOVERNORS PUSH HARD ON K-12 AGENDAS
As legislators push to wrap up business for their current sessions,
governors in Louisiana, Maryland, South Dakota, and other states have
sunk significant political capital into signature legislative and policy
initiatives on a range of education issues, including teacher tenure
and evaluation, education funding, and charter schools. The article is
in
Education Week.
COLORADO TEST OF NEW TEACHER EVALUATION SYSTEM RAISES DOUBTS
Though Colorado is more than a year away from implementing its new
teacher-evaluation system, doubts have surfaced about the state's
ability to launch such a sweeping initiative on time and with adequate
resources for professional development. Educators from some of the 27
districts piloting all or part of the new system say that effort has
turned out to be a complex and time-consuming task heaped upon demands
of other education reforms. The article is in the
Denver Post.
STATE CHIEFS TO DUNCAN: DON’T UNDERMINE US WITH WAIVERS
It's unclear just how serious Education Secretary Arne Duncan and his
top aides are when they talk about pursuing waivers for districts in
states that choose not to take advantage of a broader waiver under the
No Child Left Behind Act. But state chiefs have a message for Duncan
nonetheless: Back off the idea of district-level waivers. (Okay, so they
put it a little more nicely than that.) The post is from
Education Week’s Politics K-12 blog.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
U.S. WORKFORCE NEEDS MORE COLLEGE GRADS, LUMINA STUDY SHOWS
The number of adult Americans who have earned college degrees has been
increasing, but not fast enough to keep up with workforce demands,
according to
a report released
Monday. At the current rate, employers in 2025 will need about 23
million more degree-holders than the nation's colleges and universities
will have produced."We are nowhere near at the pace that we need to be
says," Jamie Merisotis, president of the non-profit Lumina Foundation,
which released the report. "Look at it as an alarm, an urgent call to
action." The AP story is from
USA Today.
CUTTING THE DEGREE DOWN TO THREE
Would you sacrifice part of the proverbial best four years of your life
to cut costs? Paying eight semesters' worth of tuition, room and board,
textbooks and other fees can add up to tens of thousands of dollars,
and that's if you finish college in four years. For about 60 percent of
students, the college experience takes at least another semester before
graduation. But some schools offer or are planning to debut new,
fast-track bachelor’s degree programs that hit families' wallets for
only three years. The article is in the
Chicago Tribune.
BLACKBOARD’S OPEN SOURCE PIVOT
In a turn that shocked many in the higher ed tech world, the e-learning
giant Blackboard on Monday announced that it has acquired two companies
that provide support to Moodle, the leading open-source alternative to
Blackboard’s proprietary online learning platform. As part of a raft of
announcements, the company said it has bought Moodlerooms, a major
open-source support provider in North America, and NetSpot, which serves
a similar role for Moodle users in Australia. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.ABOUT HIGHER ED
HOW TO END REMEDIATION
A bill in Connecticut, which the General Assembly’s higher education
committee passed last month, would require the state’s public
institutions to eliminate non-credit stand-alone remedial classes by the
fall of 2014. Under the policy, students who need remedial (or
developmental) coursework would be placed into entry-level,
credit-bearing courses and receive “embedded remedial support.” They
would also be required to take an “intensive college readiness program”
before the semester’s start. Currently an estimated 70 percent of
students at the state’s 12 community colleges take at least one remedial
class during their first year of enrollment. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
LOW GRADUATION RATES AT 2-YEAR COLLEGES AFFECT STUDENTS AND STATE GOVERNMENTS
Low graduation rates at community colleges have a negative effect on
the lifetime earnings of students, and on the coffers of state
governments, says a
report
released on Tuesday by the American Enterprise Institute. Halving the
dropout rate would generate $30-billion more in lifetime incomes for
160,000 new graduates and would provide an additional $5.3-billion in
taxpayer revenues to state governments, according to the report. The
information is from
The Chronicle of Higher Education.
STUDENT DEBT RISES AS POLITICAL ISSUE
The White House and Democratic lawmakers are scrambling to find funds
to stop an expected doubling of student loan interest rates this summer,
arguing that they’re heading off another potential blow to the economy.
But the new House GOP budget doesn’t include the $6 billion needed. The
article is in
Politico.
ABOUT K-12
WHEN TEACHERS ARE REPLACEABLE WIDGETS, EDUCATION SUFFERS
Robert Boruch and Andrew C. Porter from the University of Pennsylvania
Graduate School of Education, and Joseph Merlino, president of the 21st
Century Partnership for STEM Education, write in
Education Week:
We have become convinced that in our nation's struggling urban schools,
teachers and would-be education reformers are battling through a
hurricane that shows no signs of abating. We call this hurricane
"churn."Churn is a remarkable instability among school personnel that
makes it nearly impossible to build a professional community or develop
long-term relationships with students. It happens when teachers are
treated like interchangeable parts who can be moved around cavalierly to
plug a hole in a school schedule. It happens when administrators
repeatedly order teachers to switch to a different grade, teach a
different subject, or move to a different school.
GOVERNOR SIGNS BILL TO SET RULES ON READING TESTS, TEACHER EVALUATIONS
Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker signed an education reform bill that
creates the Read to Lead Development Council in the governor's office
and includes provisions such as a new early literacy screening test for
use in kindergarten and early grades. The bill also requires teacher
performance evaluations be based half on student test scores. The
article is in the
Wausau Daily Herald.ABOUT K-12
FLUNKING THE TEST
The Washington Post’s Paul Farhi writes in the
American Journalism Review:
By many important measures – high school completion rates, college
graduation, overall performance on standardized tests – America's
educational attainment has never been higher. Moreover, when it comes to
education, sweeping generalizations ("rigid and sclerotic") are more
dangerous than usual. How could they not be? With nearly 100,000 public
schools, 55 million elementary and secondary students and 2.5 million
public school teachers currently at work in large, small, urban,
suburban and rural districts, education may be the single most complex
endeavor in America. The prevailing narrative – and let's be wary of our
own sweeping generalizations here – is that the nation's educational
system is in crisis, that schools are "failing," that teachers aren't up
to the job and that America's economic competitiveness is threatened as
a result. Have the nation's schools gotten noticeably lousier? Or has
the coverage of them just made it seem that way?
MAYORS CHALLENGE TEACHERS UNIONS
As a young labor organizer in Los Angeles, Antonio Villaraigosa worked
for the city’s teachers, honing his political skills in the fight for a
good contract. The union loved him back, supporting the Democrat’s
election to the State Assembly, City Council and, finally, the mayor’s
office he occupies today. But now, Villaraigosa, a rising star in the
national Democratic Party, has a different view. He calls the teachers
union “the one, unwavering roadblock” to improving public education in
Los Angeles. Villaraigosa is one of several Democratic mayors in cities
across the country – Chicago, Cleveland, Newark and Boston, among them –
who are challenging teachers unions in ways that seemed inconceivable
just a decade ago. The article is in
The Washington Post.
TN SENATE OKS BILL TO CLOSE TEACHER EVALUATION DATA
The Tennessee Senate approved legislation to close teacher evaluation
records to parents and other members of the public. The sponsor said
access to the data should be limited to school officials. Under recent
changes to state law, half of a teacher's assessment must derive from
testing data, the rest from classroom observations. The article is in
the
Tennessean.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COMPLETION AT WHAT PRICE?
Technology and cost-cutting won’t fix the capacity crisis at community
colleges, which is freezing out hundreds of thousands of students,
warned the
first report from
a new faculty think tank. The research center is affiliated with the
Campaign for the Future of Higher Education, a national group of faculty
leaders, which was formed last year with the support of unions, faculty
senates and the Association of American Colleges and Universities. The
center will attempt to inject a stronger voice from the professorate
into the national debate over higher education, particularly around the
campaign’s seven founding principles.. With its debut report, released
today, the center takes on the “completion agenda” and its heavy
emphasis on workforce development, a fixation that the report said
threatens academic quality and student access, as well as social
mobility. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.
‘BADGES’ FILL CREDENTIAL GAPS WHERE HIGHER EDUCATION FAILS
The U.S. higher education system is looking suddenly and seriously ill
in this economic revolution we're living through. The flash-mob
restructuring of our entire economy and way of life (courtesy of the
floods of information and connectivity flowing from the Internet and
mobile technologies) is shining a harsh light on the punishing expense
and brittle bureaucracy of our college and university education system.
And now disruptive innovators are taking dead aim at the heart of the
system. Using badges. Parents (a.k.a. college- funding sources): Take
note. The article is in
The Denver Post.
THERE IS NO STUDENT LOAN CRISIS
NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Total student loan debt has topped $1 trillion
... but there's no need to panic. Most borrowers have a reasonable
amount of debt, and the total balance is not likely to cause major
damage to the economy like the mortgage crisis did, experts say. "I
don't think it's a bubble," said Mark Kantrowitz, publisher of
Finaid.org, a financial aid website. "Most students who graduate college
are able to repay their loans."
TO ENROLL MORE MINORITY STUDENTS, COLLEGES WORK AROUND THE COURTS
With its decision to take up racial preferences in admissions at public
colleges, the Supreme Court has touched off a national guessing game
about how far it might move against affirmative action and how
profoundly colleges might change as a result. But no matter how the
court acts, recent history shows that when courts or new laws restrict
affirmative action, colleges try to find other ways to increase minority
admissions. The article is in
The New York Times.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COMMUNITY COLLEGES AS FICTION FODDER
Forget campus appearances by President Obama and other politicians. A
better sign that community colleges have arrived on the national scene
may be their starring role in popular culture. A television show, a
recent Hollywood movie and two novels are set at community colleges.
Even better, they all include a healthy dollop of satire. So instead of
just mocking the sector as an academic backwater of last resort – long a
tactic of comedians – these satirical looks laugh along with community
colleges, saying in essence: “we kid, because we love.” The article is
in
Inside Higher Ed.
EDUCATION COLLEGES CRY FOUL ON RATINGS
A nonprofit advocacy group is pushing colleges of education to
participate in an effort to rate their teacher-preparation programs, but
many of the schools are balking, arguing the project is flawed. The
nation's 1,400 colleges of education have been criticized by the Obama
administration and others for lax admission standards, unfocused
curriculum and failure to provide enough real-life classroom training.
States must evaluate teacher-prep programs, but standards are so weak
that only 31 of 1,400 programs were rated subpar in 2010, the latest
data available, according to the U.S. Department of Education. The
article is in the
Wall Street Journal.
FEEDBACK FROM STUDENTS BECOMES CAMPUS STAPLE
BOSTON — Every other Monday, right before class ends, Muhammad Zaman, A
Boston University biomedical engineering professor, hands out a
one-page form asking students to anonymously rate him and the course on a
scale of one to five. Muhammad Zaman, who teaches biomedical
engineering at Boston University, graphs the results of his evaluations
and e-mails to explain how he will make changes. It asks more, too: “How
can the professor improve your learning of the material?” “Has he
improved his teaching since the last evaluation? In particular, has he
incorporated your suggestions?” “How can the material be altered to
improve your understanding of the material?” “Anything else you would
like to convey to the professor? The article is in
The New York Times.
ABOUT K-12
MATH MATTERS, EVEN FOR LITTLE KIDS
Everyone knows that children who are not reading at grade level by 3rd
grade are fated to struggle academically throughout school. Concerns
about early literacy skills are justified because reading skills at
kindergarten entry predict later academic achievement. But guess what
predicts later academic success better than early reading? Early math
skills. In
“School Readiness and Later Achievement,”
a widely cited 2007 study of large longitudinal data sets, University
of California, Irvine, education professor Greg Duncan and his
colleagues found that in a comparison of math, literacy, and
social-emotional skills at kindergarten entry, "early math concepts,
such as knowledge of numbers and ordinality, were the most powerful
predictors of later learning." The commentary, by former Stanford
Education School Dean Deborah Stipek, UC Berkeley professsor Alan
Schoenfeld, and Deanna Gomby, the vice president for education at the
Heising-Simons Foundation in Palo Alto, is in
Education Week.
BETTER LATE THAN GED
A new brief from the Center on Education Policy examines whether late
graduation is worth the extra effort for students and their schools,
finding the short answer to be yes. On-time graduation is preferable,
but a recent study from the CEP using data from the National Education
Longitudinal Study of 1988 finds that late graduation pays off in
academic outcomes and every aspect of life -- work, civic, and health.
Late graduates do markedly better than GED recipients and dropouts, and
when the data are controlled to compare students of equivalent
socioeconomic status and achievement level, late graduates come close to
on-time graduates in achievement. Late graduates are more likely to be
minority or language minority students, live in a poorer household, and
have two or more risk factors associated with dropping out. They end
middle school and start high school with skills comparable to those who
eventually drop out or receive a GED, and in the eighth grade are no
more prepared for high school math or English. But in high school, late
graduates start making better grades, though their achievement on
standardized tests stays mainly the same as eventual dropouts and GED
recipients, suggesting late graduates have more persistence. The brief
therefore recommends that schools be encouraged through accountability
systems to keep all students in school until they graduate, regardless
of how long it takes. Accountability systems should also give schools
credit for all students who graduate late, not just special education
students and English language learners. This article is from the
PEN NewsBlast.
ABOUT K-12
ESTHER WOJCICKI ON “WHY I TEACH”
An inspiring blog post from Palo Alto journalism teacher (and Carnegie friend) Esther Wojcicki for John Merrow’s
Learning Matters blog
series, “Why I Teach.” Esther writes: Why do I teach? I guess the best
answer is — because I cannot resist. I love empowering kids. I try to
create a classroom atmosphere in which students are not afraid of making
mistakes. In fact, they are encouraged to take intellectual risks and
occasionally fail, because that is the way they learn best. I promote
collaborative learning, or working on projects in groups. Who wouldn’t
have more fun working with their friends? They do. They love working
with their peers, and I facilitate that interaction setting up projects
that are both meaningful and educational.
DOWNGRADED BY EVALUATION REFORMS
Florida teacher and author Elizabeth Randall writes in
Education Week Teacher:
To evaluate teachers under the new (evaluation) requirements, all of
the schools in our district found the money to purchase iPads equipped
with iObservation software for administrators to use for documenting
their "weekly" observations of teachers. (In my case, that amounted to a
little more than an hour all year.) In addition, all of the schools are
training veteran teachers how to teach from a book by education
researcher Robert J. Marzano titled
The Art and Science of Teaching. The
new evaluation system, based on this book and implemented by the new
software on the new iPads, consists of screens and screens of teaching
strategies a teacher has to demonstrate during an evaluation (including
the use of technology, which my school doesn't even have the financial
resources to provide—for students, that is). The book is subtitled "
A Comprehensive Framework for Effective Instruction" when, in my view, it reduces teaching to a series of artificial gestures.
DUNCAN DEFENDS WAIVERS, COMPETITIVE GRANTS
The clash between the Obama administration, which loves its signature
Race to the Top and other grant programs, and folks in Congress who want
to see a bigger investment in funding for special education and
disadvantaged students, is clearly not going away anytime soon. The post
is from
Education Week’s Politics K-12 blog.
START UPS TRY TO CRACK EDUCATION MARKET
Silicon Valley is going back to school. Education, long a favorite
cause among Bay Area philanthropists, is also starting to attract
technologists who want to make money in it. That's generating a boom in
start-ups trying to make education more efficient. In recent months, Bay
Area education-tech companies such as Piazza Technologies Inc., a
question-and-answer service for students and teachers, and Desmos Inc.,
which makes a Web-based graphing calculator, have received new funding.
Overall, venture capitalists invested $429.1 million in 82
education-technology deals last year, up from $334.3 million and 58
deals the year before, according to Thomson Reuters. The article is in
the
Wall Street Journal.
ABOUT HIGHER ED
COMMUNITY COLLEGE TO CHARGE MORE FOR TOP COURSES
SANTA MONICA, Calif. — For years now, administrators at the community
college here have been inundated with woeful tales from students unable
to register for the courses they need. Classes they want for essential
job training or to fulfill requirements to transfer to four-year
universities fill up within hours. Hundreds of students resort to crying
and begging to enroll in a class, lining up at the doors of instructors
and academic counselors. Now, though, Santa Monica College is about to
try something novel. This summer it will offer some courses for a higher
price, so that students who are eager to get into a particular class
can do so if they pay more. The article is in
The New York Times.
WHY COLLEGE STUDENTS STOP SHORT OF A DEGREE
The "Pathways to Prosperity" study by the Harvard Graduate School of
Education in 2011 shows that just 56 percent of college students
complete four-year degrees within six years. Only 29 percent of those
who start two-year degrees finish them within three years. The Harvard
study's assertions are supported by data collected by the Organization
for Economic Co-operation and Development for its report "Education at a
Glance 2010." Among 18 countries tracked by the OECD, the United States
finished last (46 percent) for the percentage of students who completed
college once they started it. That puts the United States behind Japan
(89 percent), and former Soviet-bloc states such as Slovakia (63
percent) and Poland (61 percent). The article is from Reuters.
posted Mar 29, 2012 10:27 am
ENDING THE FIRST ED.D PROGRAM
Harvard University this week announced its reform: eliminating the
Ed.D. and replacing it with a Ph.D. program. The university's decision
will close the first American Ed.D., a program Harvard has offered for
90 years. The Harvard Ed.D. has enjoyed more respect than most Ed.D.
programs, so the decision to end the program is sure to rekindle an
ongoing academic debate about the need for and relevance of the Ed.D
degree.
The Ed.D. typically has traditionally been designed like a research degree, said Jill Perry, co-director of the
Carnegie Project on the Education Doctorate,
“but was delivered to teachers seeking to advance into administration
positions as practitioners. This is where the confusion began,” she
said. Many studies indicate that differences between Ed.D. and Ph.D.
programs centered around differences in the number of credits and
dissertation topics. “As a result, the Ed.D. was viewed as less rigorous
than a Ph.D., and was labeled a ‘Ph.D. Lite.’ ”
Perry said that Harvard’s move was a validation of the need to
differentiate between the two kinds of doctoral degrees and re-emphasize
the role and purpose of each. She said the Carnegie project was doing
just that, and had worked with more than 50 schools of education to
create frameworks for Ed.D. programs, or professional practice
doctorates. The goal, she said, was to equate such a degree with other
professional degree programs rather than with a Ph.D. “It is an effort
to restructure and rethink what has been the status quo as a means to
end the debate,” she said. The article is in
Inside Higher Ed.